25 Best Amazon White Elephant Gifts Everyone Will Want—Under $25

The gift you bring to the white elephant party needs to be cute, affordable, and yet, somehow appeals to the masses. It’s a tall drink order, but we’ve cracked the code with white elephant Amazon gifts everyone will want, even if they cost less than $25. 

The tricky thing about buying a white elephant gift is finding something that isn’t too personal, but still delivers on quality and style. These popular Amazon gifts do just that, with finds from top brands like Kate Spade, Apple, Laneige, Yankee Candle, and Le Creuset. They’re all hiding in The Holiday Shop at Amazon, and we pulled together a list of the best 25, starting at $10.  

Best Amazon White Elephant Gifts Overall

• Apple AirTag, $24 (was $29)
• Laneige Lip Sleeping Mask, $24
• Kate Spade Tortoiseshell AirTag Case, $25
• Yankee Candle Balsam and Cedar Classic Large Jar Candle, $17 (was $31)
• Le Creuset Mini Round Cocotte, $22
• BaubleBar Carly Bracelet, $20
• Ouai Leave In Conditioner, $16
• Vera Bradley RFID Convertible Wristlet, from $21
• Sol de Janeiro Cheirosa 62 Perfume Mist, $25
• Kasa Smart Wi-Fi Plug Mini Pack, $11 with coupon (was $20)

No matter who claims your present, rest assured they’ll try to hide it from getting stolen during the game, especially with the items below that are perfect for the hostess, home chef, fashionista, and beauty guru. Discover top-sellers like Stanley water bottles, Ugg socks, Sol de Janeiro perfume, and Voluspa candles. These are just a few options, so scroll through to find even more good buys. We won’t tell if you buy a few for yourself!   

Best Amazon Home Gifts 

The cutest home finds make some of the best holiday gifts. Case in point: these picks from Yankee Candle, Le Creuset, and Stanley. In addition to being stylish, the presents also prove to be extremely functional, which is a feature Real Simple readers love. For example, this adorable Le Creuset holiday mug is made with stoneware to ensure drinks stay hot longer. Meanwhile, this Voluspa candle smells comforting, but it also acts as decor when unlit. 

Vobaga Electric Mug Warmer

This clever electric mug warmer will be one of the most sought after presents under the tree. Designed with a hot plate and three heat settings, the mug warmer keeps drinks piping for up to four hours. It comes in six fun colors, including light blue, green, and pink. 

Bedsure Striped Flannel Fleece Throw Blanket

Elegant, sophisticated, and gorgeous—three adjectives to describe this Bedsure fleece throw. The ribbed stitch gives the blanket a high-end appearance, and the flannel fleece makeup delivers a soft feel shoppers can’t get over. It’s available in sizes ranging from throw to king, but we’d go with the smaller option for a white elephant shindig. 

Best Amazon Fashion Gifts 

Accessories are your best bet for a white elephant party, so you can focus on the style not the size. Score Rifle Paper Co. totes, Vera Bradley wristlets, Kate Spade AirTag holders, and then some, starting at $17. If you really want to shop for clothing pieces, we found a few oversized or slouchy knit options that anyone will want, including this chunky sweater and these super-soft Ugg socks. 

Ugg Cozy Chenille Socks

You might have hated receiving socks for Christmas as a kid, but now they’re all the rage—and this pair from Ugg deserves a top spot on any wish list. Made with a blend of soft polyester and stretchy spandex, the fuzzy socks are soft to the touch and relaxed, making them ideal for hours-long movie nights. 

Kate Spade Vegan Leather Luggage Tag

Kate Spade purses might be out of the budget, but you can still add a bit of luxury to any travel bag with this luggage tag. Unlike plain—dare we say, boring—tags, this Kate Spade option is all about fun with its bright green color and cute “Where to next?” design. The faux leather pick has a window to display your personal information and has a gold buckle, so you can switch it from the duffel to the suitcase. 

Best Amazon Beauty Gifts

Diamonds may be a girl’s best friend, but skincare just might be a close second. Gifts that’ll treat friends to a spa-like experience are ideal, especially ones from Brooklyn Botany, Burt’s Bees, and Laneige. Score hydrating lotions, body scrubs, nail polishes, and fragrance sprays that they may not think to buy for themselves… which is why you will. Oh, and they’ll love you for it. 

Laneige Lip Glowy Balm

Real Simple readers and shopping editors are obsessed with Laneige’s Lip Glowy Balm, which delivers a dose of hydration with each swipe. Formulated with shea and murumuru butters, the balm leaves lips feeling soft and looking glossy. 

Brooklyn Botany Brown Sugar Scrub

Remember that spa treatment we were talking about? This Brooklyn Botany scrub is where it’s at. It’s made with brown sugar granules that exfoliate skin, leaving it feeling softer than a baby’s bottom. And thanks to the almond and jojoba oils in the formula, the scrub will replenish the skin’s moisture—not strip it.