Tories must aim to be broad church, urges James Cleverly

Potential Tory leadership contender James Cleverly has urged the party not to “narrow our offer” as it seeks to rebuild after its election thrashing.

Writing in the Times, the shadow home secretary said the party should aim to be a “broad church” to win back voters from left and right.

It comes after senior Tories on the right of the party urged it to focus on winning back former Tory voters who opted for Nigel Farage’s Reform UK.

On Tuesday, former cabinet minister Suella Braverman urged the party to build its offer around “core Conservative policies”.

Addressing a right-wing Tory group on Tuesday, she backed a departure from the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) and accused government bodies of harbouring a “lunatic woke virus”.

So far no Tory MPs have declared they will run in the contest to replace former prime minister Rishi Sunak as the next Conservative leader.

A timetable is yet to be announced, with a number of Tories suggesting they would favour a longer contest concluding later this year.

Other possible leadership contenders include Kemi Badenoch, Tom Tugendhat, Victoria Atkins, all ministers under Mr Sunak at the election.

Former home secretary Priti Patel has also been tipped to run, as has Robert Jenrick, who quit as Mr Sunak’s immigration minister last year after a row over legislation to deliver the now-ditched Rwanda deportation scheme.

The Conservative vote dropped to 6.8m in last week’s election, down from 13.9m at the last election in 2019, sparking a furious debate over what the party should do next as it seeks to recover its standing with voters.

Reform UK, which ran on a platform of cutting migration, slashing foreign aid and leaving the ECHR, garnered 4.1m votes, winning give seats.

Some figures on the right of the party, including Ms Braverman, have said the focus should be on winning back Reform voters, many of whom backed the Conservatives at the 2019 election.

But in his Times article, Mr Cleverly warned: “The Conservative Party has always been at its best when it embraces being a broad church.

“We lost voters to the left and the right, and we won’t win them all back if we narrow our offer,” he added.

He said the party should not “descend into bitter infighting and finger pointing”, adding that the immediate focus should be becoming a “credible opposition” to Sir Keir Starmer’s newly-minted Labour government.

Rules for the contest are yet to be decided, with some Tories arguing that the current system, under which MPs choose two contenders to go before a vote of party activists, should be overhauled.

Some Tories have said party members should lose their casting vote on the winner – a move that would require changing the party’s constitution, and is likely to be fiercely resisted by MPs on the right of the party.

Bob Blackman, the newly-elected chair of the 1922 committee that will set the leadership election rules, said members should get the “ultimate say”.

Speaking to BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, he added he wanted potential candidates to get “exposure in Parliament” so other MPs, as well as party members, can see how they perform in opposition.

Surveys of party members for ConservativeHome, a popular website among activists, have suggested Ms Badenoch has the highest approval ratings among members of the mooted leadership contenders.

This was also borne out in a survey by pollsters YouGov for researchers at Sussex University and Queen Mary University of London, the first such poll of Tory members opinion since last week’s election.

It put Ms Badenoch as the most popular, followed by Ms Braverman, Mr Tugendhat and then Mr Cleverly.